Apostasy, The Great
noun · historical theology
Catholic
The Catholic Church does not recognize a "Great Apostasy" — a total collapse of the Church Christ founded. Christ's promise that "the gates of hell shall not prevail" against His Church (Mt 16:18) is understood as a guarantee of indefectibility: the Church may suffer corruption, heresy, or persecution, but it cannot cease to exist or lose the deposit of faith entrusted to it. Individual members and even clergy may apostatize; the Church itself cannot.
Latter-day Saint
A foundational LDS claim is that the primitive Church established by Christ fell into complete apostasy shortly after the death of the Apostles, losing both its authority and its doctrinal integrity. This universal apostasy — leaving no true church on earth — is said to have necessitated a complete restoration through Joseph Smith in 1820. Without this premise, the Restoration has no rationale.
Key Tension →
The Great Apostasy theory requires Christ's promise in Matthew 16:18 to have failed within a generation. Catholic theology holds this to be impossible by divine guarantee. See: The Ante-Nicene Church Fathers and Their Catholic Doctrines.
Apostolic Succession
noun · ecclesiology
Catholic
The unbroken chain of episcopal ordination from the Apostles to the present college of bishops, by which the authority, sacramental power, and teaching office of the original Apostles are transmitted across time. This succession is both historical (documented) and sacramental (effected through valid ordination). It is the basis for the Church's claim to binding authority in matters of faith and morals.
Latter-day Saint
LDS theology denies the legitimacy of traditional apostolic succession, arguing the chain was broken during the Great Apostasy. Authority was not transmitted but entirely lost, and could only be restored — not recovered — through direct angelic visitation. John the Baptist is said to have restored the Aaronic Priesthood to Joseph Smith in 1829, and Peter, James, and John the Melchizedek Priesthood.
Key Tension →
If traditional succession was legitimate enough to transmit authority to the Apostles and their first successors — as even LDS theology implicitly concedes — the case for its total rupture requires an argument beyond mere historical decline. See: The Ante-Nicene Fathers.
Atonement
noun · soteriology
Catholic
Christ's suffering, death, and resurrection constitute a single redemptive act that objectively reconciles humanity to God and merits the grace necessary for salvation. The atonement is infinite in scope — sufficient for all, applied through faith and the sacraments. It is completed and unrepeatable, though made present in every Mass through the unbloody representation of Calvary.
Latter-day Saint
The LDS Atonement is understood to have occurred primarily in the Garden of Gethsemane rather than on the cross (a distinctive emphasis). Its scope is conditioned by obedience to gospel laws and ordinances. The Atonement enables resurrection for all (universal), but exaltation — the highest degree of salvation — requires compliance with temple ordinances, celestial marriage, and related covenants.
Key Tension →
The Pauline insistence that justification is by grace through faith — not works of law (Rom 3:28; Gal 2:16) — stands in tension with an Atonement that is conditioned upon performance of specific ordinances for its fullest application. See: Progressive Revelation vs. Primordial Dispensationalism.